Save
Ready to make the spookiest treat on the block Dracula Dentures are my number one pick for a Halloween party platter Every single bite is a sweet and silly surprise which is why I have made these every October since my kids were in preschool They are easy for little hands to help assemble and always make people laugh
I first whipped these up for a last minute classroom party and ended up fielding recipe requests from all the teachers and parents Truly a crowd pleaser that vanished fast
Ingredients
- Chocolate chip cookies: You can use homemade or store bought as long as they are sturdy enough to slice Tip Look for cookies with a slightly chewy interior but crisp edges so they hold up to frosting
- Mini marshmallows: These become the teeth Fresh marshmallows are easiest to work with so skip leftovers from last season
- Red frosting: This creates the gums Use gel or classic canned frosting for best sticking power and bold color
- Slivered almonds: These make the fangs Pick uniform pieces that are not too thick for the best look
- Chocolate frosting (Optional): Add for extra detail around the gums or to help hold things together Choose a spreadable type not a glaze
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Prepare the Cookie Halves:
- Cut each chocolate chip cookie cleanly in half You want two curved pieces that will be the top and bottom of your dentures Use a gentle sawing motion with a sharp knife to avoid too many crumbs
- Add the Gums:
- Spread a thin but even layer of red frosting on the flat side of each cookie half Be generous near the curved edge so it shows as gums
- Arrange the Teeth:
- Line up mini marshmallows snugly along the curved side of one cookie half These are your teeth Try to choose even sizes and fill the length of the curve
- Build the Dentures:
- Set the other cookie half on top with the frosted side facing down toward the marshmallows Press very gently until the marshmallows stick but keep their shape This forms your classic denture sandwich
- Insert the Fangs:
- Slide two slivered almonds into the marshmallow row about 1 inch apart on the front These are the vampire fangs Place them at angles for a natural look
- Add Realism (Optional):
- Dab chocolate frosting along the inside or outside edges to look like darker gums or create a shadow effect You can also use it to patch any cookie cracks Chill slightly before serving if you want neater lines
Save
You Must Know
- This is a no bake recipe perfect for last minute gatherings
- Kids love to help assemble the teeth and fangs
- You can use gluten free or allergy friendly cookies as needed
Watching my youngest niece build her own dentures for the first time and proudly show off her creation to the entire family made my heart melt The fangs are always the biggest hit everyone personalizes theirs a little differently which adds to the fun
Storage Tips
Store Dracula Dentures in an airtight container in a cool spot to prevent the frosting from melting If you need to stack them place a piece of wax paper between layers for best results These are best enjoyed within one day but can last up to two days if refrigerated just bring them to room temperature before serving for best texture
Ingredient Substitutions
Swap out the slivered almonds for pumpkin seeds or white chocolate chips if you need a nut free version If red frosting is not available use white frosting tinted with a dot of gel food coloring Need vegan Try vegan cookies and marshmallows which are now easy to find in many stores
Save
Serving Suggestions
Arrange your Dracula Dentures on a black or blood red platter for maximum Halloween effect Scatter extra mini marshmallows around as “fang fallout” and serve with cold milk or a bubbling cauldron of punch These are perfect as a finger food for both kids and grown ups just keep some napkins handy
Cultural and Party Fun
Halloween treats like these are all about playful creativity The idea actually goes back to vintage party magazines where people crafted edible smiles and monster faces for tricks and treats Over the years my family has turned Dementor Dentures into a tradition every October we make a new batch with silly themes
Common Recipe Questions
- → Can I use homemade cookies instead of store-bought chocolate chip cookies?
Absolutely! Homemade cookies add a personal touch and allow customization of texture and flavor while keeping the structure sturdy enough for assembly.
- → What type of frosting works best for the gums?
A thick, vibrant red frosting holds the marshmallows in place and gives an authentic spooky effect. Buttercream or ready-made frostings work well.
- → How do I keep the marshmallows from sliding?
Press the marshmallows gently into a generous layer of frosting and don't overfill to ensure they stay put when sandwiching the cookie halves.
- → Are there alternatives for slivered almonds as fangs?
White candy melts or pumpkin seeds can serve as fang alternatives, especially for those with nut allergies or different taste preferences.
- → How far ahead can I assemble these treats?
They are best enjoyed fresh but may be made a few hours in advance and stored in the refrigerator to prevent softening or sliding ingredients.