Authentic Chicago Italian Beef

This hearty Chicago Italian Beef Sandwich has been my weekend tradition every football season. The combination of tender, slow-cooked beef soaked in aromatic broth and stuffed into crusty bread creates an authentic taste of Chicago right in your home kitchen. While it takes some time to prepare, the results are well worth the wait and will transport you straight to the Windy City with every bite.

I first made this sandwich during a particularly bitter Chicago winter when I was homesick for authentic local food. My family was so impressed they now request it for every major gathering, especially when friends come over to watch sports.

Ingredients

• Beef chuck roast: ideal for slow cooking as it breaks down beautifully and absorbs flavors look for well marbled pieces
• Olive oil: use a good quality oil that can handle high heat cooking
• Onion and garlic: creates the aromatic base for the broth choose firm onions with no soft spots
• Beef broth: use low sodium to control salt levels better quality broth means better flavor
• White vinegar: adds essential tanginess that cuts through the richness of the beef
• Worcestershire sauce: provides depth and umami notes always shake the bottle well before using
• Dried oregano and basil: these herbs are classic Italian flavor builders crush between your fingers before adding to release oils
• Red pepper flakes: optional but recommended for authentic Chicago heat use sparingly if sensitive to spice
• Italian rolls: the bread makes or breaks this sandwich look for crusty exterior with soft interior
• Giardiniera: traditional Chicago topping with pickled vegetables and chili heat levels vary so choose accordingly

Step-by-Step Instructions

Sear the Beef:

Heat olive oil in a large Dutch oven over medium high heat until shimmering but not smoking. Pat beef chuck roast completely dry with paper towels and season generously with salt on all sides. Place the roast carefully in the hot oil and let it cook undisturbed for a full 5 to 7 minutes until deeply browned. Using tongs flip and repeat on all sides including the edges. This critical step creates the foundation of flavor for the entire dish so be patient and get good caramelization.

Build the Flavor Base:

Remove the seared beef and set aside momentarily. Reduce heat to medium and add sliced onions to the pot scraping up all the browned bits from the bottom. Cook onions for about 2 minutes until they begin to soften and turn translucent around the edges. Add minced garlic and cook for 30 seconds more until fragrant but not browned. The pot should smell incredibly aromatic at this point.

Create the Braising Liquid:

Return the beef to the pot and pour in beef broth water white vinegar and Worcestershire sauce. Add all dried herbs black pepper and red pepper flakes if using. The liquid should come about halfway up the sides of the beef if not add a bit more broth. Bring the mixture to a gentle simmer not a rolling boil which would toughen the meat.

Slow Cook to Perfection:

Reduce heat to low so the liquid barely bubbles cover the pot with a tight fitting lid and allow the beef to braise for at least 3 hours preferably 4. Check occasionally to ensure liquid level remains consistent adding more broth if needed. The beef is done when it easily shreds when pressed with a fork. The longer cooking time allows the connective tissues to break down completely resulting in that signature tender texture.

Shred and Marinate:

Once tender remove the beef to a cutting board and shred using two forks pulling against the grain for the best texture. Return all shredded meat back to the pot with braising liquid and let it sit for at least 15 minutes to soak up more flavor. This step is crucial for authentic Chicago style beef.

Assemble the Sandwiches:

Split Italian rolls and toast them lightly if desired. Using tongs pile generous portions of the shredded beef onto each roll along with some of the flavorful broth. Top with your choice of giardiniera or sautéed sweet peppers. For the authentic experience dip the entire assembled sandwich briefly into the hot broth before serving the classic Chicago wet style.

Save

The giardiniera topping is my absolute favorite part of this sandwich. My grandmother who lived in Chicago for 40 years taught me that the spicy pickled vegetable mix adds the perfect contrast to the rich beef. She always said a proper Italian beef should drip down your arms when you eat it a messy but essential part of the authentic experience.

Make Ahead Options

The beauty of Chicago Italian beef lies in how well it keeps and even improves with time. You can prepare the entire beef portion up to three days ahead and store it in the refrigerator in its cooking liquid. The flavors will continue to develop and intensify making this perfect for busy weekends or entertaining. When ready to serve simply reheat the beef and liquid together over low heat until warmed through. This approach actually creates an even more flavorful sandwich as the beef has more time to absorb all those wonderful seasonings.

The Chicago Dip Debate

Authentic Chicago beef sandwiches come in three traditional styles dry with very little broth dipped where the assembled sandwich is quickly dunked in broth or wet where the beef is soaked in broth before being placed on the roll. Each method delivers a different eating experience from relatively neat to gloriously messy. I personally prefer the middle option dipped which gives you moisture without the bread completely falling apart. For firsttimers I suggest starting with dry or dipped before working up to the full wet experience which requires quick eating and plenty of napkins.

Regional Variations

While the classic Chicago Italian beef recipe remains relatively consistent across the city different neighborhoods have developed their own subtle variations. Some South Side shops add a sprinkle of dried Italian seasoning to the broth while others on the West Side might include bell peppers in the braising liquid. The North Side tends to favor a slightly spicier giardiniera topping. At home feel free to adjust the seasonings to your preference the beauty of making this iconic sandwich yourself is the ability to customize while maintaining the authentic elements that make it special.

Save

Common Recipe Questions

→ What cut of beef works best for Chicago Italian Beef?

Chuck roast is ideal because it has excellent marbling that becomes tender when slow-cooked. Other good options include rump roast or round roast, though they're slightly leaner. The key is a tougher cut that benefits from long, slow cooking to break down connective tissues.

→ What is giardiniera and can I substitute it?

Giardiniera is an Italian pickled vegetable relish made with cauliflower, carrots, celery, and peppers in vinegar and oil. It comes in hot or mild varieties. If unavailable, substitute with pepperoncini, pickled jalapeños, or sautéed sweet bell peppers for a different but still delicious flavor profile.

→ What's the difference between 'dipped,' 'wet,' and 'dry' Italian beef?

'Dry' means the beef is served without extra jus. 'Wet' means the beef is loaded with extra cooking liquid. 'Dipped' means the entire assembled sandwich is briefly dunked in the hot jus before serving, creating a deliciously messy experience where the bread absorbs the flavors.

→ Can I make Chicago Italian Beef ahead of time?

Yes! The beef actually improves with time as it absorbs more flavors. Cook the beef completely, then store it in its cooking liquid in the refrigerator for up to 3 days. The chilled fat will rise to the top and can be removed before reheating for a less greasy sandwich. Simply reheat on the stovetop when ready to serve.

→ What type of bread works best for Italian beef sandwiches?

Traditional Chicago Italian beef sandwiches use Italian-style rolls with a crusty exterior and soft interior. The crust should be sturdy enough to hold up to the juicy meat, especially if you're dipping the sandwich. French bread, hoagie rolls, or ciabatta rolls can work well as substitutes.

→ Can I make this in a slow cooker or pressure cooker?

Absolutely! For slow cooker, sear the beef first, then cook on low for 8-10 hours. For pressure cooker or Instant Pot, sear the beef, add all ingredients, and cook on high pressure for 60-70 minutes with a natural release. Both methods yield tender, flavorful beef perfect for sandwiches.